Re: That's the Wrong Alex

[Home] [Chat] [Forums] [Search] [ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Martial Arts Table Talk ]

Posted by Well then on September 17, 2003 at 20:08:33:

In Reply to: Re: That's the Wrong Alex posted by KC Elbows on September 17, 2003 at 18:29:54:

So what your saying is that a martial artist, by your account, a good martial artist, with a history of known chinese kungfu
practice of at least (what would you say) half a dozen or 10 years of practice and study under Kam Yuen went and joined Chung
M00 Quan, and stuck with it long enough to become an instructor (1st, 2nd degree?)

This raises a couple of questions:


If the form and techniques at schools is as shoddy as yourself and other anti-moos claim, why did such a stellar martial artist as
you claim this student was remain in training long enough to achieve 1st or 2nd degree?


Are you saying he learned nothing from The Northern Tai Mantis Teacher Kam Yuen (who he studied from before taking Chung
M00 classes) that would dissuade him from continuing with Chung M00 studies and becoming an instructor of Chung M00
himself.


It would appear you are either saying that he couldn't help but see that Chung M00 was a fraud and wanted to take part in the
deception, but quit because of politics.


Or that he couldn't discern that for years that he was studying a bad martial art but at the same time was somehow good enough
at martial arts to win your acclaim, but he was not good enough to realize that he was teaching 'bad' martial arts?


The other possibility is that the Chung M00 being taught was good form and technique and he just went to do something else for
either politics or some other, unmentioned (by yourself) reason.


HMMM


Follow Ups:

Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:

[Home] [Chat] [Forums] [Search] [ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Martial Arts Table Talk ]